Don’t drown in the sea of sameness: A destination branding paradox

Hotelling Beach
Frank Cuypers

30 November 2016

Destination marketers tend to believe that good branding is about standing out in the crowd. This is understandable, as traditional marketing training encourages new marketers to create unique, compelling messaging that simply must be heard due to its creativity and emotional resonance.

This creates a problem and a classic branding paradox: If everyone tries to stand out from the same crowd, everyone’s doing the same thing. How can a marketer create a truly unique brand in an environment where everyone is trying to be unique in exactly the same way?

Hotelling’s Law and the sea of sameness

Let’s pretend we’re at the beach.

It’s a beautiful day, and two ice cream carts are at points A and C on Hotelling Beach. Cart A sells vanilla and cart C sells chocolate ice cream. They’re both doing some good business, but the owners want to compete with each other and increase their market share, maybe so that they can both take their own beach vacation later. How will they do this?

Hotelling Beach

Harold Hotelling was a Stanford University economist who defined an economic theory involving a principle of minimum differentiation, or law of averageness, which says that “rival sellers tend to gravitate toward each other — in location, price, and product offerings — because otherwise they risk losing some of the broad mainstream of customers.”

In this case, according to Hotelling’s Law, they will both try to convert customers by luring them away from the competitor and moving toward the middle, point B.

Under this principle, the ice cream carts on Hotelling Beach will likely move closer together in location, match prices, or change flavours to become more like the other, instead of seeking to differentiate themselves further. Beachgoers could then face a choice between two almost identical blends of chocolate and vanilla at point B – a bland, beige compromise.

This is hardly the quest for uniqueness called for by modern branding.

You can see this principle in effect in politics, where candidates often move to the centre to avoid losing mainstream votes; fast food chains, which offer very similar burgers and fries in close proximity; and even between destinations branded with the same “gourmet culinary scene,” “vibrant arts scene,” or “best beaches” as their next-door neighbours.

It’s all about making connections

Every destination believes its food is unique and its culture is extraordinary, and maybe this is for the best. Marketing a destination requires passionate advocates.

But that’s exactly the point: Branding a destination is about the ability to make connections with the truly unique, passionate communities that flow naturally from its authentic identity.

Instead of using the traditional, outmoded branding approach, tell the truth, and maybe with a bit of humour. For example, the Charleroi Safari, a tour of Belgian industrial ruins, embraces its “ugliest city in the word” identity. Promote Iceland tells the truth through its very helpful and funny Inspired by Iceland video series. Its “Pack Warm and Stay Happy” video helps visitors prepare for unpredictable Icelandic weather that can include “rain, shine, or sudden snowstorm.”

Both of these destinations express their true “sense of place” proudly and openly. This honesty and openness will be your destination’s best life preserver in the sea of sameness.

Related reading: Why place branding needs to be built from the inside

6 Comments

  1. Michelle Dunn

    I agree 100 per cent! Well said.

    Reply
  2. Anna

    Great article as always Frank. I especially like

    Branding a destination is about the ability to make connections with the truly unique, passionate communities that flow naturally from its authentic identity.

    Reply
    • Frank Cuypers

      Thank you Anna ! I’ve recently worked with places that ask to avoid words as ‘branding’ and ‘marketing’ and prefer ‘community’, ‘reputation’ or ‘identity’. Interesting times….

      Reply
  3. Gug Girard

    Frank,

    This is so close to reality it is scary. Neighboring communities are mimicking each other across the country and losing their originality and clouding their messaging. Communities have been dumb downed by DMOs for so long they are scared to think for themselves to the extent they rely on DMOs for everything and have lost their sense of originality. Hence, why we are working with some small communities to build their brands, extend seasons and promote their physical inventories using a real-time content marketing strategy. Slow slog though as changing minds is a slow process. Great article Frank.

    Reply
    • Kristy Molnar

      Thanks – Frank & ehCanada Travel. Harrison Hot Springs needs to up the ante in expanding its focus beyond the Hotel Resort monopolized hot springs – there is so much to discover locally and in the area if only you stay more than a day … tired to those looking to come up for “just a soak”. Help Tourism Harrison and all of us get the message out! The Rockwell Harrison Guest Lodge B&B (Luxury surrounded by Nature)

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

RELATED POSTS

You’ve found your partner for destination marketing

We work with the most innovative tourism boards in the world to create a vision for each of their destinations, solve business challenges and execute brilliant, integrated campaigns. The expertise we apply to that work is shared in the articles published here and in our DMO Matters newsletter.

Get must-read updates delivered weekly!

Sign up to have our must-read weekly digest of leading destination marketing trends and innovation delivered directly to your inbox.

Fields marked with an * are required.

Consent*

Thank you! You will receive an email to confirm your subscription.

Share This